Well, the Cardinals definitely weren’t messing around when they said they were buyers. They added a former 16-game winner!
All eye-rolling aside, I like Joel Pineiro’s chances of contributing at least as much as those of, say, Mike Maroth, and he’s certainly better than Jorge Sosa on the Mid-Season Retread scale. As with most retreads, though, his recent statistics do not tell a lovely story; they illustrate a Kip Wellsian saga of lurking on the cusp of ace-hood and then struggling to do much of anything afterward. Some arbitrary but very edifying endpoints:
GS W L IP/G K/9 BB/9 HR/9 K:BB
2002-2004 81 36 29 6.75 6.6 2.8 1.05 2.30
2005-2006 55 14 23 6.01 4.7 3.0 1.17 1.58
Losing two strikeouts a game is very rarely a good thing. Pineiro has never had elbow surgery, but a fat lot of good that’s done him; he’s had elbow problems on and off for the last three years, and it’s cost him a fair amount of velocity on his heavy two-seam fastball. But apparently the Cardinals are–
Wait, wait, back up a little.
–Jeff Weaver used to be really good! I think he’s got a chance to–
No, no, forward.
–Mike Maroth used to be kind of good! I think he’s got a chance to–
Little more.
–heavy two-seam fastball–
Ahh. Now the acquisition makes sense. Back when he was a future stud Pineiro’s fastball was described by Baseball Prospectus as Tim Hudson-esque, but his groundball ratios have never been much to write home about.
That said, this is another pitcher right in Dave Duncan’s wheelhouse–a mediocre veteran with the makings of a Cardinals-Special sinker whose strikeouts do not appear to be coming back. Nothing wrong with taking this flier, whether the Cardinals are in contention or not; it’s not like he’s blocking anybody.
Of course, the Cardinals’ sudden decision to start winning games did have one unfortunate side effect: their old, effective bullpen has been left completely untouched, aside from the former starters who’re about to end up in the back of it. Meanwhile, useful players such as Wilson Betemit were getting traded for Found Arms on the same day that Chris Perez, our anointed closer of the future, struck out two of three batters he faced in his AAA debut.
Whether you’re sellers or, as the Cardinals appear to be, very reluctant buyers, you can’t pass up a chance to get young talent for guys you plucked out of the ether months or, in the case of Percival, weeks ago.